Assassins Creed Valhalla Who Betrayed Rollo Complete Choice Guide

During the Essexe arc in Assassin's Creed Valhalla, players must assist a Viking captain named Rollo in uncovering a traitor within his camp. The investigation during the "Old Wounds" quest forces Eivor to evaluate clues and determine whether Lork or Gerhild leaked information to Saxon forces. Identifying the true culprit is essential for ensuring a smooth narrative progression and protecting key allies later in the storyline.

Investigating the Camp Clues and Suspect Alibis

When investigating Rollo's camp, Eivor can interrogate both Gerhild and Lork to hear their respective accounts of the attack. Both suspects initially claim they were out hunting rabbits, but inspecting the meat rack reveals it is already full. Further exploration using Odin's Sight reveals a hiding spot in the tall grass near the camp perimeter.

Upon further questioning, Lork admits that he was actually sleeping in the woods and hid in the grass when the Saxons struck. Gerhild claims she was meeting a Saxon lover, which is suspicious given her vocal resentment toward Rollo's relationships with Saxons. Evaluating these conflicting statements helps reveal who is truly lying about their whereabouts.

Identifying the Traitor: Why Gerhild is Guilty

The true traitor who betrayed Rollo is Gerhild. Her alibi falls apart under scrutiny because she lies about hunting despite the camp having ample food supplies. Additionally, her deep-seated jealousy regarding Rollo's alliance with Estrid gives her a clear motive to conspire with enemy Saxons.

In contrast, Lork is bound by a strict blood oath to Rollo and served Rollo's father honorably for many years. His age and frailty explain why he chose to hide during the sudden ambush rather than fight. Accusing Gerhild prompts Rollo to execute her on the spot, eliminating the threat to his crew.

Consequences of Choosing the Wrong Suspect

If Eivor incorrectly accuses Lork, Rollo executes his loyal warrior while Gerhild goes free. This mistake leads to direct consequences later in the Essexe storyline when Estrid attempts to escape to Francia. Gerhild remains alive to sabotage the plan, ultimately injuring Estrid during her departure.

Correctly naming Gerhild prevents this disaster and allows Lork to protect Estrid during the final stages of the quest. Choosing the right traitor ensures a successful outcome for Rollo's allies and secures a cleaner resolution to the arc.